Home Healthy Food Home made Thousand Island Dressing – Match Foodie Finds

Home made Thousand Island Dressing – Match Foodie Finds

Home made Thousand Island Dressing – Match Foodie Finds


This do-it-yourself Thousand Island dressing recipe is so scrumptious and straightforward to make, you’ll by no means return to purchasing store-brand once more! A traditional combination of mayo, Greek yogurt, ketchup, pickles, and extra make this creamy dressing completely swoon-worthy.

A salad with chicken, tomatoes, and avocado on a plate.

For those who’re a Thousand Island dressing fan, maintain on to your seat belts, as a result of this particular sauce will change your thoughts about ever shopping for the store-bought model! We love Thousand Island dressing right here at Match Foodie Finds as a result of it’s so versatile. You need to use it on something from salads (ahem, our crispy rooster salad was fairly actually MADE for this dressing 😏), burgers, tacos, a dipping sauce for fried appetizers or uncooked veggies, and extra!

It’s really easy to whip up this traditional dressing for any event, because it’s able to serve in a matter of some minutes. So subsequent time you’re pondering of heading to the shop to seize a bottle of Thousand Island, have a look in your pantry and fridge. Chances are high, you’ve gotten all the pieces it’s essential to make your individual do-it-yourself model that tastes brisker and higher than ever.

why we love this do-it-yourself dressing

  • A straightforward, budget-friendly choice.
  • Made with actual, recent components that you just really know and love.
  • Tremendous versatile as it may be used on many alternative dishes.
  • Filled with scrumptious creamy goodness!

Our Go-To Thousand Island Components

  • Mayonnaise: mayo acts as a wealthy, creamy base for this dressing.
  • Greek yogurt: provides a pleasant tangy taste and creamy factor to the sauce. Don’t skip it!
  • Ketchup: you may’t have Thousand Island dressing with out ketchup!
  • Yellow onion: onion offers the dressing with a tasty pungent taste to offer it a pleasant kick.
  • Pickles: historically, this dressing is used with pickled relish, however we love the way it tastes with dill pickles!
  • Pickle juice: pickle juice provides a briny, barely candy taste that’s simply yum! 😀
  • Sugar: sugar provides a sweeter style that balances out the tangy and savory components.
A bowl of ingredients with a whisk in it.

Learn how to Make Home made Thousand Island Dressing

For the total recipe, scroll right down to the recipe card for an inventory of components and directions.


In a small bowl, add the mayonnaise, greek yogurt, ketchup, minced yellow onion, pickles, pickle juice, and sugar. Combine totally till mixed. 


As soon as all the pieces is all combined collectively, your do-it-yourself dressing ought to be creamy and easy. Place it within the fridge to permit the dressing to relax and thicken.


Now it’s time to take pleasure in your scrumptious dressing! Take it out of the fridge and use it as a dressing for salad, marinade for protein, and even as a topping for burgers. Take pleasure in!

Strive our Crispy Rooster Salad Recipe

This crispy rooster salad is breaded with cornflakes (sure, you heard that proper!) and tossed with romaine lettuce, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, avocado, almonds, and feta cheese — an ideal touchdown place for this tasty do-it-yourself Thousand Island dressing.

A bowl of sauce with a whisk in it.

Different Methods to Use Home made Thousand Island Dressing

Who mentioned you ONLY might use this Thousand Island dressing on a salad? Listed below are another nice dishes that carry the scrumptious taste of this dressing to life:

Appetizers to Dip

Burgers to Sauce

Tacos to High

A jar of sauce with a wooden spoon next to it.


What does thousand island dressing style like?

Some say it’s just like the lovechild of ketchup and mayonnaise. Others discover that it tastes a bit like vinaigrette with a touch of sweetness. 

However actually, Thousand Island dressing is what YOU make it — you may customise it nevertheless you need! Be happy so as to add extra mayo for those who’re into creamier dressings or some chili flakes for those who want a spicy kick. Experiment and make it your individual!

Why is it known as thousand island dressing?

Thousand Island Dressing is claimed to have originated within the stunning Thousand Islands area of New York State on the flip of the 20th century. Legend has it a fishing information’s spouse, Sophie Lalonde, whipped up a scrumptious mixture of mayonnaise, ketchup, pickle relish, Worcestershire sauce, and a hard-boiled egg to feed her husband for dinner. 

The dressing finally made its method to the tables of some notable company, and as phrase unfold about this tantalizing new condiment, it shortly grew to become often known as Thousand Island Dressing. It has remained a diner favourite ever since.


Retailer any leftover thousand island dressing in an hermetic container within the fridge for as much as 7 days.

A jar of ketchup with a wooden spoon.

​Extra Home made Dressing Recipes

A salad with chicken, tomatoes, avocado and dressing on a plate.

Home made Thousand Island Dressing Recipe

A traditional combination of mayo, Greek yogurt, ketchup, pickles, and extra make this do-it-yourself thousand island dressing completely scrumptious. By no means purchase store-bought once more!

Prep:5 minutes

Whole:5 minutes


  • Add all the components for the Thousand Island Dressing right into a bowl and blend to mix.

  • Place the dressing within the fridge for later for those who’re not serving instantly.

  • Serve over salads, as a burger sauce or as a dip.

Vitamin information

Energy: 95kcal Carbohydrates: 7g Protein: 1g Fats: 7g Fiber: 0.2g Sugar: 6g



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here